The More You Sell, The More You Make

The More You Sell, The More You Make

By Jim Cory

At a home improvement company, no position turns faster than sales. Turnover rates of 50 percent or more are not uncommon at some big companies. Imagine replacing your production manager or your office manager every other year?

Selling home improvement is, salespeople say, a hard way to make an easy living. The pay is almost always commission only but the commissions—anywhere from 7 to 12 percent, depending on job size—are good. If you sell a million dollars worth of roofing, siding or windows, you’re sitting pretty. But it’s also risky. If you as a rookie can’t get up to speed quickly, you’re cut. Sales veteran who hits a slump? You may linger till the owner’s patience is exhausted, but that won’t be forever.

Sell And You Make Money

A good reason for this is that it costs a lot of money to create sales appointments. Home improvement companies spend five or six times as much as the average business on marketing. So the person you want to send to the house is someone with the confidence to convince prospects to buy. Confidence comes from training, and then from succeeding, so many companies pay an initial salary, which reps are typically weaned off of when they come into their own.

 “We train people for 90 days,” says Ger Ronan, president of Yankee Home Improvement in Chicopee, MA. In those three months, sales candidates at Yankee are paid $500 weekly. After 90 days, it’s commission only. At Hullco  in Chattanooga, TN, sales candidates spend six weeks training. They start running leads after two and for the next four weeks their compensation is a combination of salary plus five percent commission on what they sell. When training ends, they’re offered the option of continuing with that. Most, says general manager Brian Brock, elect to go commission-only, because at that point they know how to sell.

Why It Works

This has been the way it is for a long time. Meanwhile the larger world of selling has moved more and more to a mixed base-plus-commission system (typically 30 percent base, 70 percent commission). Some home improvement company owners have experimented with different compensation plans, but lead costs and the need for solid motivation to close make a salary system untenable in the minds of most. “Why should I pay a base when we’re giving them ten leads a week at $300 a lead?” says Miles Wilkins, owner and CEO at The Board Store Home Improvement, in La Crosse, WI.

Do the math and you may see his point. At ten leads a week, you’re spending $3000. In 50 weeks a year, $150,000.

Wilkins says salespeople at his company—there are six—are compensated at steadily elevated commission levels. Write a million or more, you’re at ten percent. Like many owners, he provides a draw against future commissions. That way, every other Friday there’s a check, even if someone’s numbers are off.

‘Me First’ Mentality

Two things could shake all this up. The first is that some homeowners won’t put up with the close-at-all-costs behavior which commission only sales inspires in certain people. Jeff Brooks, co-owner of Solid State Construction in Shirley, MA, found this out a few years ago. Until 2014, Brooks, who comes from a home improvement sales background, did all the selling for the company.  Then volume reached the point where he had to hire salespeople. The salespeople came from companies where the one call close reigned supreme. In time, he became aware of a clash between the company’s commitment to a great customer experience and the manner in which sales appointments were being conducted. Reps blew off appointments they didn’t find promising, and high-pressured customers into buying. It was, Brooks says, “a Me First mentality.” People impressed by the company’s reputation were far less impressed by what went on in a sales appointment. Brooks had to rehash the messes. Negative comments began appearing in reviews.

Last year he changed his sales compensation plan to a three-tiered salary system. The first thing he noticed was a “night and day” difference in the quality of job applicant. “We saw people with college degrees and management backgrounds applying for these jobs,” he says.

He completely replaced the sales force, but even with a rookie team of five, close rates in 2018 are six percent higher than they were in 2017.

Changing Paradigm

The other thing working against commission only pay plans is the generational shift underway. Last year in LinkedIn Roberta Chinsky Matuson pointed out that “today, it’s much harder to sell young people on a career in sales…”. Twenty-somethings often see salespeople as untrustworthy or buffoonish, the cultural stereotype. Throw in commission-only compensation and a job selling windows is less appealing still.

Brock says the millennials he’s recruited want two things: flexibility and appreciation. “Sometimes we have to sell them on it,” he says. And what still sells is money. Someone who masters the art of home improvement sales can take home “a quarter million dollars a year.” Though obviously not everyone will.

Beyond recruiting there’s the retention issue. The longest-serving salesperson at The Board Store has been there 25 years, but La Crosse is not a major metro market and millennials tend to job hop.

You have to wonder if, at big companies with high turnover, it isn’t inconvenient to have the sales manager spend half his time recruiting, hiring and training. What’s left for coaching and team building? The high turn model of sales management also presupposes an inexhaustible supply of candidates for sales positions. Which might be true—there are always people looking—but not if you want the right ones.

Should Intuition Play Any Part in Hiring?

Going by your gut can lead to costly hiring mistakes. But is it wise to ignore intuition altogether? Intuition—feeling—always plays some role in hiring. You may not be aware it does, but it does.

This Is How We Do Things Here

Which comes first, job skills or cultural fit? Culture can be anything from really bad to really great, really great meaning employees manage themselves with spectacular results. Here’s what it might look like at your organization:

Body Snatchers

Competitors actively recruiting from among your staff can only succeed if you let them. Learn about creating a workplace culture where employees don't want to leave.

Cut Me Some Slack

If you hope to attract and keep great people today, bet on flexibility. Manage around employee needs, which lets them know those needs are real to you as well as to them.

Always Looking For Stars

You can call top performers whatever you want to call them, but figure out how to keep them. It was Jack Welch, General Electric’s CEO, who popularized the idea of A, B and C employees. Fair or unfair—

Culture of Advancement

Want a great team? Create opportunities and train people for them. To most home improvement company owners, singed in putting out the daily fires, that must read like Fantasyland. But it’s not if you’re willing to learn about HR, hiring, retention, and training.

How Bad Hires Happen

It’s not a good feeling when it’s clear your new employee isn’t going to work out. A hiring mistake is of two types. The first, someone revealed to be completely incompatible with the culture of a company. The second, someone lacking skills and capabilities.

The Apprentice

Who wants to be an electrician? How about a framing carpenter? Raise your hand. If you were standing in front of most high school classes anywhere in the U.S., chances are what you’d see in response to that question would be not so much raised hands as bewildered faces.

Start Spreading The Word

Incentives and the right culture motivate employees to help you solve your recruiting problem. Learn how to setup an Employee Referral program from the industry's best.

Dream Job

Veteran home improvement salespeople call it “a hard way to make an easy living.” Daily rejection. Night and weekend hours. At what point do you let that mediocre performer go? Or should you?

The Game is Talent

It’s not news that installers are hard to find. Everybody’s talking about it. The difficulty in hiring labor points to a bigger problem, which is attracting young people to an industry that’s hardly a career destination.

Baby On Board

Your new hire arrives. How that’s going to work out is mostly up to you. Many home improvement companies hire only when they have to and preparing that new employee for success is an afterthought.

Short And Sweet – Job Fairs

Contractor associations and individual companies turn to job fairs to meet potential employees. While job fairs aren’t new, they’re a recent development in the home improvement industry. Job fairs can telescope the recruiting process into a few hours.

Second Chancers

If you desperately need people but dismiss out of hand the idea of hiring someone with a record, it might be time to take another look. Managing people successfully is about managing the individual.

Wanted: Hungry, Humble, and Smart

If you’re looking for employee installers, hire for attitude and be willing to train. Top replacement contractors discuss their training programs and how it is paying dividends.

Learning To Get By

English-speaking installers may be convenient but in many trades they’re no longer the majority. If you’re in the exterior contracting business, chances are good you’re using crews who don’t speak English.

Second Time Around

Companies once viewed former employees as gone for good once they left the company. Now it’s welcome back with arms wide open.

Reality Check

Every home improvement company is looking for people. So why would they want to work for yours? First off, what do the people you value want from an employer, and do you offer it?

Custom Solutions

It was standing room only in the meeting room at the Baltimore Convention Center last October. The topic: Labor. That is, a shortage of it. Owners are being forced to improvise.

Normal People

Profiling can be a key recruiting piece but it’s up to you to manage them.Larry Closs, owner of Maxhome, in New Orleans, is “totally sold” on profile assessments to avoid mis-hires.

Thank You For Being Here

Culture is king at home improvement companies with long-term employees. Advice from top contractors on how to think long term and create a culture of loyal, engaged employees.

In Sales: People Skills Predict Success

How do you know when that sales rookie is ready to fly solo? This month's column examines when to hand over that $350 lead to a new sales rep and how to predict future sales success.

How Big Are Your Benefits?

Many home improvement companies juggle the need to attract and retain employees with wisely managing expenses and cash flow. This month's column offers insight for finding a balance.

Hard Truths, Soft Costs

Owners often discover what someone’s worth only when they have to hire a replacement. Jim Cory examines the real value of good employees in this month's column.

Recruit Like You Market by Jim Cory

Shane Schuckman is looking for a canvas manager. In the last year and a half, the company he co-owns and manages Renewal by Andersen of Phoenix - has had seven.